Rumor has it

Rumors have it that Roy Halladay and his agent are staying in a hotel in Philadelphia. According to these rumors, Halladay is set to take a physical for the Phillies. They are also saying that the Phil’s are trying to deal Cliff Lee.
While the Phillies are actively pursuing Halladay, there are some parts of these reports that are bothersome.

First: Trading Lee to the Blue Jays for Halladay straight up is absolutely absurd. If they are looking to unload Halladay’s salary for future talent, then getting Lee will not help them considering he only has one season remaining on his current contract.

Second: Having a three team deal that includes dealing Lee makes no sense. Lee is a strikeout pitcher who the Phillies have for at least the 2010 season. While he reaches free agency next season, Ruben Amaro Jr. has been said to have been discussing an extension with Lee’s agent.

Third: Even if the Phil’s do somehow land Halladay, the price will be similar to what it was in July. The Blue Jays will want young talent that could include J.A. Happ, and possibly one of two of the Phil’s top prospects in outfielder Dominick Brown or pitcher Kyle Drabek.

Four: In order to give up that young talent, the Phil’s will have to guarantee a contract extension with Halladay before the trade is complete. With their current salary and their limited budget it wouldn’t be feasible without dealing a major player on the team. Halladay, at the age of 33, by the time next season begins will most likely command CC Sabbathia money (around $20 MM a year).

Other rumors have linked the Phillies to veteran pitcher John Smoltz. Smoltz has received offers from multiple teams according to mlb.com. The Phil’s would look to add the veteran for bull pen help.

In other Phillies news, the team has non-tendered reliever Clay Condrey. The Phil’s can still offer a contract to Condrey, but they were unable to agree on a salary number before the non-tender deadline.

They did however, offer contracts to the other three players who were arbitration eligible (Shane Victorino, Joe Blanton, and Carlos Ruiz). Essentially all three of those players have been signed to one-year contracts for the 2010 season. In addition to those three, Chad Durbin was also offered a contract.